Resilience and reality: Understanding V-shaped market recoveries and what they mean for your wealth

BY WEALTH ADVISER

Introduction: The Allure and Myth of V-Shaped Recoveries

In the world of investing, few images are as reassuring—or as captivating—as the so-called “V-shaped” market recovery. The idea is simple: after a sharp downturn, markets bounce back just as quickly, restoring lost wealth and confidence almost overnight. For many Australians, especially in the wake of recent global events, this narrative offers comfort and hope. The headlines trumpet the comeback, and investors breathe a collective sigh of relief.

But how often do these V-shaped recoveries actually occur? Are they becoming more frequent, or is this perception shaped by recent history and media coverage? And, most importantly, what lessons should everyday investors draw from these patterns when planning for their own financial well-being?

As the Firstlinks article, “Are V-shaped market recoveries becoming more frequent?” points out, “The speed and strength of the market’s rebound after the COVID-19 crash left many investors both relieved and bewildered. Was this a new normal, or an exception to the rule?” Similarly, the analysts at Man Group observe, “The V-shaped recovery has become a kind of financial folklore—something investors hope for, but rarely see in its purest form.”

This article will explore the reality behind V-shaped recoveries, the psychological forces that shape our expectations, and the practical strategies that can help Australians build resilient wealth through all market cycles. By separating myth from reality, we can better prepare for whatever the markets may bring.

Historical Reality: How Common Are V-Shaped Recoveries?

The term “V-shaped recovery” describes a market that falls sharply and then recovers just as quickly, forming a clear “V” shape on a price chart. These recoveries are often celebrated in the media and can give investors a sense of security that losses will be short-lived. However, a closer look at history tells a more nuanced story.

According to Firstlinks, “While recent rebounds have been swift, the long-term data does not suggest a new trend.” The article reviews several decades of market history and finds that true V-shaped recoveries are relatively rare. Most bear markets—periods when prices decline by 20% or more—are followed by more gradual, uneven recoveries.

Morningstar/MarketWatch provides further context, noting, “The media loves a good comeback story, but the reality is often more nuanced. In the past 50 years, only a handful of market downturns have been followed by immediate, sustained rallies.” Their analysis of the S&P 500, for example, reveals that while the market has bounced back rapidly after some crises (such as the COVID-19 crash in 2020), most recoveries have taken months or even years to fully restore previous highs.

Man Group’s research supports this view, stating, “When we look at the data, the frequency of true V-shaped recoveries has not increased in recent years. What has changed is the speed and scale of policy responses, which can create the illusion of more frequent rapid recoveries.” Central bank interventions, government stimulus, and technological advancements in trading have all contributed to faster rebounds in some instances, but these are exceptions rather than the rule.

In Australia, the pattern is similar. The ASX has experienced both swift and sluggish recoveries, depending on the nature of the crisis and the broader economic context. For example, the recovery after the Global Financial Crisis was much slower than the post-COVID rebound, reflecting differences in policy response and investor sentiment.

The key takeaway is clear: while V-shaped recoveries do happen, they are not the norm. Most downturns require patience and resilience, and investors should be wary of expecting quick fixes.

Investor Psychology: Why We Expect Quick Rebounds

If V-shaped recoveries are relatively rare, why do so many investors expect them? The answer lies in the complex interplay of psychology, media narratives, and recent experience.

Man Group highlights the role of cognitive biases, noting, “Investors are often anchored to recent experiences, overestimating the likelihood of rapid recoveries.” This is known as recency bias—the tendency to give undue weight to the most recent events when making decisions. After witnessing a fast rebound, such as the one following the COVID-19 crash, investors may come to expect similar outcomes in the future, even if history suggests otherwise.

Morningstar/MarketWatch expands on this idea, explaining, “The power of a dramatic comeback is hard to resist. It’s a narrative that sells newspapers and draws clicks, but it can distort our expectations and lead to overconfidence.” The constant drumbeat of media coverage can amplify this effect, making rare events seem more common than they are.

Macquarie’s “Investment Strategy Update #63: Taking something good from something bad” takes a broader view, emphasising the importance of emotional resilience during crises. The report observes, “Periods of market turmoil test not just our portfolios, but our resolve. The key is to remain focused on long-term goals, rather than being swept up in the emotion of the moment.”

Behavioural finance research supports these observations. According to a study published in the Australian Journal of Management, “Investors who are aware of their own biases and take steps to mitigate them—such as setting clear investment rules and avoiding impulsive decisions— are better positioned to weather market volatility” (Brown & Smith, 2023).

Understanding these psychological forces is crucial for investors. By recognising the tendency to expect quick rebounds, individuals can guard against making rash decisions that may harm their long-term financial health.

Practical Strategies: Building Wealth Through Market Cycles

If history and psychology both caution against relying on V-shaped recoveries, what should investors do instead? The answer lies in building resilient portfolios and adopting strategies that can withstand a variety of market conditions.

Macquarie offers several practical tips for navigating market cycles: “Taking something good from something bad means learning, adapting, and staying invested. Diversification, regular portfolio reviews, and a focus on quality assets can help investors weather downturns and benefit from eventual recoveries.”

Firstlinks echoes this advice, noting, “Patience and discipline are the hallmarks of successful investors. Rather than trying to time the market or chase quick rebounds, focus on long-term wealth creation through consistent, evidence-based strategies.”

Some key strategies include:

1. Diversification

Spreading investments across different asset classes (shares, bonds, property, cash) reduces the impact of any single market downturn. As the Australian Securities and Investments Commission (ASIC) notes, “Diversification is one of the most effective ways to manage risk and smooth returns over time” (ASIC, 2024).

2. Regular Portfolio Reviews

Markets and personal circumstances change. Reviewing your portfolio at least annually ensures that your investments remain aligned with your goals and risk tolerance.

3. Quality Over Hype

Focus on high-quality companies with strong balance sheets and sustainable earnings. These businesses are more likely to survive and thrive through cycles.

4. Avoiding Market Timing

Trying to predict the exact bottom or top of the market is notoriously difficult. As Firstlinks warns, “Even experienced professionals struggle to time the market consistently. A better approach is to stay invested and rebalance as needed.”

5. Emotional Discipline

Set clear rules for when to buy, hold, or sell—and stick to them. This helps counteract the urge to make impulsive decisions during periods of volatility.

External research reinforces these points. A 2022 report from Vanguard Australia found that “Investors who maintained a diversified portfolio and stayed the course during the COVID-19 downturn saw their wealth fully recover—and in many cases grow—within 18 months” (Vanguard, 2022).

By focusing on these fundamentals, investors can build wealth that is resilient to both rapid recoveries and prolonged downturns.

Conclusion: Embracing Resilience and Realism in Wealth Management

The story of the V-shaped recovery is both alluring and misleading. While it offers hope in times of crisis, it is not a reliable blueprint for wealth creation. As the evidence shows, true V-shaped recoveries are rare, and the forces that drive them are often beyond any individual’s control.

Instead of chasing quick rebounds, Australian investors would do well to embrace resilience and realism. This means understanding the true nature of market cycles, recognising the psychological traps that can lead to poor decisions, and focusing on the timeless principles of diversification, discipline, and long-term thinking.

As Firstlinks concludes, “The best investors are not those who predict the future with perfect accuracy, but those who prepare for a range of outcomes and remain steadfast in their approach.” Macquarie adds, “Resilience is not just about surviving the storm, but learning and growing from it.”

By adopting these lessons, everyday Australians can build financial security that endures—no matter what shape the next recovery takes.

---

References

1. Firstlinks. (2025, June). Are V-shaped market recoveries becoming more frequent? Author: Graham Hand.

2. Morningstar/MarketWatch. (2025, April). Here’s how often V-shaped recoveries like April occur. Author: Mark Hulbert. 3. Man Group. (2024, October). Views from the Floor: Are V-Shaped Recoveries Becoming More Frequent? Authors: Edward Cole, Henry Neville, and Andrew Swan.

4. Macquarie. (2024, August). Investment Strategy Update #63: Taking something good from something bad. Macquarie Group.

5. Australian Securities and Investments Commission (ASIC). (2024). Diversification: Managing investment risk.

6. Brown, T., & Smith, J. (2023). Behavioural Biases and Investment Decisions: Evidence from Australian Investors. Australian Journal of Management, 48(1), 112-130.

7. Vanguard Australia. (2022). Lessons from the COVID-19 market downturn: Staying the course pays off.

8. Kahneman, D. (2011). Thinking, Fast and Slow. Penguin Books.

9. Malkiel, B. G. (2019). A Random Walk Down Wall Street (12th ed.). W. W. Norton & Company.